The Daily Lob
Where the price is wrong

The Daily Lob

MLB + NFL + NHL + ATPThursday 15 October 202611 games

NLCS Game 4 with Milwaukee one win from the World Series, Seattle at Denver on Thursday night, the hockey slate, and two Shanghai quarterfinals overnight. Football and hockey are now laid out category by category, with the pick going to whichever side wins clearly more of them. How to read this: for each game we work out what the chances should be, then compare that with what the betting odds say.

Baseball: NLCS Game 4Milwaukee lead 3–0

MIL at LAD8:00 PM ET · Dodger Stadium
Glasnow against a Milwaukee bullpen game: the Dodgers have the better arm, and must winMoney line MIL +130 / LAD −155 (opened LAD −185) · fair odds 41.7 / 58.3

Tyler Glasnow's expected ERA (what it should be, judged by how hard hitters actually hit him) is 2.88; Shane Drohan's is 3.81, and Milwaukee are using Drohan only to open a bullpen game. The pick is the Dodgers.

The money has gone the other way: Los Angeles opened at −185 and are now −155, about four points of win chance towards Milwaukee.

Against it  Drohan will probably not face the lineup twice, so the starter comparison matters less than usual, and Milwaukee's bullpen has been the best thing in this series. Glasnow walked five in his last start and has had back trouble this year. Last night's pick was the Dodgers too, behind a better starter, and Snell gave up three home runs.

StarterIPERAxERAERA − xERAK%BB%Barrel%Hard-hit%Exit velo
Shane DrohanMIL · LHP124.24.193.81+0.3823.78.38.538.788.7
Tyler GlasnowLAD · RHP74.03.532.88+0.6534.08.78.538.490.1
DrohanIPHERBBKPitchesFastballWhiff %
Sep 24at PHI2.231224794.75
Sep 12vs CIN3.255246095.428
Sep 4at CIN4.056257894.530
Aug 29vs TEX5.061169994.530
Aug 23vs ATL5.082358395.124
GlasnowIPHERBBKPitchesFastballWhiff %
Oct 7at ATL4.211557896.823
Sep 24vs SD6.1332119195.943
Sep 18vs SF6.0322109895.740
Sep 12at MIA4.054479195.537
Sep 5vs WSH6.064389695.633

Football: Thursday nightcategory by category; the pick goes against the spread

SEA at DEN8:15 PM ET · Empower Field
Seattle win three categories to one; the rating says the spread is about rightMarket SEA −2.5 (opened −2) · ELWAY: SEA −2.05

Seattle have the better quarterback, the best defence in the league against a middling Denver offence, and they face a secondary without Pat Surtain II and Talanoa Hufanga. Three categories to Denver's one, so the pick is Seattle −2.5.

The rating itself has no quarrel with the line: it makes Seattle two-point favourites, half a point from the market.

Against it  That is the catch with this card: the categories say who is better, and the spread already says Seattle. The ratings were set before Week 5, when Seattle lost at home to San Francisco. The total has fallen a point and a half to 40.5, and in a low-scoring game a field goal decides whether 2.5 is covered.

SEADENEdge
SpreadSEA −2.5 · opened −2 · money line about −145DEN +2.5 · total 40.5, down from 42—
Rating v the spreadELWAY rates Seattle about four points better than Denver on a neutral fieldHome field is worth 1.75 · ELWAY makes it Seattle by 2.05even
QuarterbackDarnold, healthy, three straight starts since his hip injury · the higher-rated of the twoNix, healthy, started all fiveSEA
Offence v defenceOffence 9th against Denver's defence 9th · 26.8 points a gameOffence 11th against Seattle's defence, 1st · 19.4 points a gameSEA
Last three games1–2, +2 · lost 32–29 at home to San Francisco on Sunday2–1, even · won 23–17 at the Chargers on Sundayeven
InjuriesOut: running back Charbonnet, linebackers Drake Thomas and Surratt · Smith-Njigba and Leonard Williams expected to playOut: cornerback Pat Surtain II, safety Talanoa Hufanga · cornerback Riley Moss questionableSEA
Rest and travelShort week, a time zone east, and up to altitudeShort week at home, after flying back from Los Angeles on Sunday nightDEN

Edges: SEA 3 · DEN 1 · even 2

Hockey: seven games where one side wins the categoriesthe pick needs at least two more categories than the other side; widest first

PHI at DET7:30 PM ET · Little Caesars Arena
Detroit win all six categoriesOdds PHI +120 / DET −142 (opened DET −135) · fair odds 44.3 / 55.7

Philadelphia have had far the worst of the chances of any team on tonight's slate, lost all four games last week by a combined nine goals, and are without Konecny and two top-four defencemen. Detroit have been unlucky: level on chances this season and five goals down. The pick is Detroit.

The odds give Detroit 56% and the ratings 56%, so nobody is arguing about the favourite, only about how much.

Against it  Detroit have not won in regulation for a week either, and their goalie, Tarasov, has only two games this season. Philadelphia's goalie, Woll, is not confirmed.

PHIDETEdge
Odds44% · opened 45%56% · opened 55%—
Expected v actual goals, last 3Created 6.1, allowed 9.6 · scored 4, let in 11Created 9.7, allowed 11.7 · scored 7, let in 11DET
Expected v actual goals, seasonChances −13.5 over eight games, the worst on the slate · goals −20Chances about level · goals −5: dueDET
Goalie tonightWoll (unconfirmed): .914, about three better than average this season; below average last seasonTarasov (confirmed): .974 in two games; about average last seasonDET
Ratings (Elo)44%56% at homeDET
InjuriesKonecny, York, Ristolainen, Grebenkin outCompher, Kasper, Appleton outDET
Last week0–3–1, goal difference −90–1–2, goal difference −5DET

Edges: PHI 0 · DET 6 · even 0

VAN at FLA7:00 PM ET · Amerant Bank Arena
Florida win five of six, even without Barkov and MarchandOdds VAN +240 / FLA −298 (opened FLA −300) · fair odds 28.3 / 71.7

Vancouver lost all four games last week by a combined 20–7 and have had the second-worst share of the chances on the slate. Florida are short of Barkov, Marchand, Gudas and Markstrom, and still win every category except injuries. The pick is Florida.

At 72% this is a short price: a win returns a third of the stake.

Against it  Florida's injury list is long and includes their best two forwards. Merilainen has been decent this season for Vancouver after a very poor one last year.

VANFLAEdge
Odds28%72%—
Expected v actual goals, last 3Created 7.1, allowed 10.9 · scored 5, let in 13Created 11.2, allowed 11.8 · scored 11, let in 12FLA
Expected v actual goals, seasonChances −9.8 in eight games · goals −12Chances +1.1 · goals −1, slightly dueFLA
Goalie tonightMerilainen (confirmed): about two better than average this season, about 17 worse last seasonSchmid (confirmed, Markstrom hurt): about average over both seasonsFLA
Ratings (Elo)26%74% at homeFLA
InjuriesDemko out; Chytil backBarkov, Marchand, Gudas, Markstrom outVAN
Last week0–4, goal difference −131–2, goal difference −1FLA

Edges: VAN 1 · FLA 5 · even 0

CGY at VGK10:00 PM ET · T-Mobile Arena
Vegas win four, but Calgary are the unluckiest team in the leagueOdds CGY +260 / VGK −325 (opened VGK −295) · fair odds 26.8 / 73.2

Vegas have had a goal a game more of the chances than their opponents this season and went 3–1 last week. The pick is Vegas, at 73%.

Calgary's season is a warning, though: their chances are almost level and their goal difference is −17, the biggest gap between the two on the board.

Against it  That kind of gap does not last, and Calgary have had more of the chances than Vegas over the last three games. Both goalies have been below average.

CGYVGKEdge
Odds27% · opened 29%73% · opened 71%—
Expected v actual goals, last 3Created 10.6, allowed 9.3 · scored 9, let in 13Created 7.6, allowed 8.8 · scored 9, let in 7CGY
Expected v actual goals, seasonChances −1.9 · goals −17: very dueChances +8.0, a goal a game · goals +9VGK
Goalie tonightWolf (confirmed): about six worse than average this seasonHart (confirmed): about average this season, below lasteven
Ratings (Elo)25%75% at homeVGK
InjuriesHuberdeau, Honzek outWotherspoon, Olofsson outVGK
Last week1–2, goal difference −43–1, goal difference +3VGK

Edges: CGY 1 · VGK 4 · even 1

NYI at OTT7:00 PM ET · Canadian Tire Centre
Ottawa win three and lose none; the Islanders have been winning beyond their playOdds NYI +136 / OTT −162 (opened OTT −160) · fair odds 40.5 / 59.5

The Islanders are four goals up on the season while being outplayed on chances, the clearest case on the slate of a team ahead of itself. Ottawa win the season row, the rating and last week. The pick is Ottawa.

Linus Ullmark has been one of the best goalies in the league this season, about seven goals better than average in five games.

Against it  Ullmark was well below average last season, so we score the goalie row even. Ottawa are missing Sanderson and Eklund; the Islanders are without Barzal.

NYIOTTEdge
Odds40%60%—
Expected v actual goals, last 3Created 8.7, allowed 8.6Created 8.5, allowed 8.4even
Expected v actual goals, seasonChances −3.3 · goals +4: ahead of their playChances about level · goals +1OTT
Goalie tonightVarlamov (confirmed): one game this season, little sinceUllmark (confirmed): .948, about seven better than average this season; about 13 worse last seasoneven
Ratings (Elo)38%62% at homeOTT
InjuriesBarzal, Romanov outSanderson, Eklund, MacDermid, Matinpalo outeven
Last week2–1, goal difference +23–1, goal difference 0OTT

Edges: NYI 0 · OTT 3 · even 3

STL at MIN8:00 PM ET · Grand Casino Arena
The categories pick the underdog: St LouisOdds STL +120 / MIN −142 (opened MIN −160) · fair odds 43.8 / 56.2

St Louis have had the better of the chances over the last three games, went unbeaten in regulation last week, and Minnesota are missing Faber, Spurgeon and both Folignos. Three categories to one, so the pick is St Louis at +120.

The money agrees: Minnesota have drifted from −160 to −142.

Against it  The rating disagrees strongly, giving Minnesota 65%, and Jesper Wallstedt has been the best goalie in this edition: about seven better than average in six games. St Louis's Hofer is not confirmed, and Buchnevich is away for the birth of his child.

STLMINEdge
Odds44% · opened 41%56% · opened 59%—
Expected v actual goals, last 3Created 10.9, allowed 6.5 · scored 14, let in 8Created 11.9, allowed 8.8 · scored 10, let in 8STL
Expected v actual goals, seasonChances +3.0 · goals +3Chances +2.8 · goals +5even
Goalie tonightHofer (unconfirmed): about two better than average this season, about 12 better lastWallstedt (confirmed): about seven better this season, six better lasteven
Ratings (Elo)35%65% at homeMIN
InjuriesBuchnevich (personal), Tucker, Mailloux, Toropchenko outFaber, Spurgeon, both Folignos, Sturm, Gustavsson outSTL
Last week2–0–1, goal difference +62–2, goal difference +1STL

Edges: STL 3 · MIN 1 · even 2

UTA at EDM9:00 PM ET · Rogers Place
Utah win four categories, and the money has already rushed to themOdds UTA −115 / EDM −105 (opened EDM −140) · fair odds 50.9 / 49.1

Utah have had the most of the chances of any team on the slate this season and have been unlucky over the last three games; Edmonton are seven goals ahead of their chances and missing Hyman, Nugent-Hopkins and goalie Andersen. The pick is Utah.

Their stand-in, Devon Levi, has 13 NHL games and has been well below average in them.

Against it  The line has swung from Edmonton −140 to Utah −115 and we could not find out why. A move that size without a public reason is worth respecting, and it has taken most of the value.

UTAEDMEdge
Odds51% · opened 44%49% · opened 56%—
Expected v actual goals, last 3Created 11.4, allowed 8.1 · scored 10, let in 11Created 7.8, allowed 7.7 · scored 12, let in 4UTA
Expected v actual goals, seasonChances +7.0, a goal a game · goals +8Chances +4.4 · goals +11: ahead of their playUTA
Goalie tonightVejmelka (confirmed): about average this season, seven better lastLevi (confirmed, Andersen hurt): about eight worse than average in nine games two seasons agoUTA
Ratings (Elo)39%61% at homeEDM
InjuriesCarcone outHyman, Nugent-Hopkins, Andersen, Walman and three more outUTA
Last week2–1, goal difference −12–0, goal difference +5EDM

Edges: UTA 4 · EDM 2 · even 0

SJS at NSH8:00 PM ET · Bridgestone Arena
Nashville win four categories, but the goalie row goes to San JoseOdds SJS +110 / NSH −130 (opened NSH −145) · fair odds 45.8 / 54.2

Nashville have had more of the chances over three games and the season, rate higher, and lost less last week. The pick is Nashville.

Juuse Saros was nine goals worse than average last season, though, and Alex Nedeljkovic has been about average.

Against it  The money has moved two points to San Jose since the open, and this is the narrowest of the seven: four categories to two.

SJSNSHEdge
Odds46% · opened 44%54% · opened 56%—
Expected v actual goals, last 3Created 7.7, allowed 10.4Created 8.2, allowed 8.6NSH
Expected v actual goals, seasonChances −7.9 · goals −7Chances −2.8 · goals −2NSH
Goalie tonightNedeljkovic (confirmed): about average over both seasonsSaros (likely): about average this season, nine worse lastSJS
Ratings (Elo)45%55% at homeNSH
Injuriesnone listedBourque, Trudeau and back-up goalie Annunen outSJS
Last week1–2, goal difference −41–1–1, goal difference −1NSH

Edges: SJS 2 · NSH 4 · even 0

Tennis: Shanghai quarterfinalsovernight into Friday, times Eastern, both 'not before'

Medvedev v PaulFri 6:00 AM ET · Shanghai
The ratings give Paul a better chance than the odds doOdds Medvedev 1.45 / Paul 2.74 · fair odds 65.4 / 34.6

The odds give Daniil Medvedev 65%. The hard-court ratings give him 60%, which leaves Tommy Paul at 40% against the odds' 35%. The pick is Paul.

Paul has not dropped a set this week and saved eight break points against Bergs; Medvedev did not face one against Tsitsipas.

Against it  Medvedev leads their meetings 4–1 and is 3–0 against Paul on hard courts, and the money has moved three points towards him since the open. This is his first event since he was defaulted in Beijing, and he has looked untroubled by it.

Odds sayMedvedev 65% · Paul 35%
Ratings sayMedvedev 60% · 5 points apart, on Paul
LineOpened Medvedev 1.53 / Paul 2.68 · now 1.46 / 2.94 · 3 points towards Medvedev, away from the ratings
This weekMedvedev: Struff, Svrcina, Tsitsipas 6–4 7–5 · Paul: Vallejo, Vacherot, Bergs 7–6 6–4, no sets dropped
Head-to-headMedvedev 4–1 · Indian Wells 2025 6–4 6–0 to Medvedev; Rome 2024 (clay) to Paul
Jodar v RuudFri 2:30 AM ET · Shanghai
No pick: the ratings and the odds agree on Jodar, narrowlyOdds Jodar 1.78 / Ruud 2.04 · fair odds 53.4 / 46.6

The odds give Rafael Jodar 53%, the ratings 55%.

Jodar has come from a set down in all three of his matches here. Casper Ruud has played 35 minutes since Sunday: Auger-Aliassime retired with a knee injury at 5–2 in the first set.

Against it  The money has drifted four points towards Ruud since the open. They have never played.

Odds sayJodar 53% · Ruud 47%
Ratings sayJodar 55% · under two points apart
LineOpened Jodar 1.70 / Ruud 2.27 · now 1.84 / 2.08 · 4 points towards Ruud
This weekJodar: Tirante, Lehecka, Van de Zandschulp, all from a set down · Ruud: Bu, Tien, Auger-Aliassime (retired 5–2)
Head-to-headnever played
How yesterday's picks went

The Dodgers lost Game 3 6–2: Snell, the reason for the pick, gave up three home runs. Davidovich Fokina went through when Gea retired injured at 4–1 in the first set; we grade that as void, since many bookmakers return stakes when a set has not been completed. Washington and Colorado are graded on the hockey page.

Not carded. Four hockey games make no pick because neither side wins two more categories: Buffalo at Toronto, Seattle at Tampa Bay, the Rangers at New Jersey (Shesterkin is out for the season) and Winnipeg at Chicago. Jodar v Ruud is carded but makes no pick: the ratings and the odds are under two points apart. ALCS Game 3 was played this afternoon: Cleveland won 3–2 and lead 2–1. The doctors on X could not be read again.  ·  ERA − xERA negative means the results have outrun the contact.  ·  Baseball: pitch counts and game logs from MLB's stats API; expected ERA, barrels, hard-hit, fastball speed and whiff rate from Baseball Savant; prices from SportsbookReview and DraftKings. Football: ELWAY ratings supplied by the editor on 10 October, before Week 5's games; results from ESPN; injuries from the teams' own reports. Hockey: team and goalie game logs from MoneyPuck (shootout goals not counted); Elo from elo.harvitronix.com with 50 points of home ice; goalies from Daily Faceoff. Tennis: hard-court ratings from Tennis Abstract, last updated 5 October; prices are the Tennis Explorer average with the bookmakers' cut removed.  ·  Sources & methods
The Daily Lob Sources & methods