The Daily Lob
Where the price is wrong

The Daily Lob

MLB + NFLThursday 24 September 20264 games

Three night games where the first-five price can be checked against the contact quality, and the football game. Tonight the market is close to right almost everywhere — the largest disagreement on the board is a quarter of a run.

SD at LAD10:10 PM ET · Dodger Stadium
The starters are level. The price is not.F5 SD +140 / LAD −180 · fair odds 39.3 / 60.7 · total F5 4.5

Pivetta and Glasnow arrive with the same expected ERA to within two hundredths — 2.92 against 2.94 — and Pivetta owns the better raw ERA of the two.

The market still prices Los Angeles at 60.7% over five innings, which means essentially none of this number is about the men on the mound. It is the lineups, in a market that is supposed to be the pitchers'.

Against it  Pivetta has thrown 30 innings all season around elbow inflammation, so his expected line is built on a sample a single bad start would move. A Dodgers lineup edge is also a real thing to pay for, even in five innings.

StarterIPERAxERAERA − xERAK%BB%Barrel%Hard-hit%
Nick PivettaSD · RHP30.03.302.92+0.3829.25.89.035.9
Tyler GlasnowLAD · RHP67.23.462.94+0.5233.08.78.539.2
LAA at SEA9:40 PM ET · T-Mobile Park
Los Angeles under-priced by 0.25 runsF5 LAA +180 / SEA −225 · fair odds 34.0 / 66.0 · total F5 4.5

On ERA the starters are 2.18 runs apart and Seattle is a 66% favourite over five innings. On expected ERA the gap is 1.93.

Both pitchers have been unlucky rather than lucky — Rodriguez by 0.58 runs, Woo by 0.33 — so the correction is small and it runs towards the Angels.

Against it  A quarter of a run is inside the noise, and Rodriguez's 45.6% hard-hit rate is the worst of the six starters on this page. This is a lean, not a play.

StarterIPERAxERAERA − xERAK%BB%Barrel%Hard-hit%
Grayson RodriguezLAA · RHP87.06.105.52+0.5820.19.78.945.6
Bryan WooSEA · RHP167.23.923.59+0.3324.45.37.042.8
CIN at ATL7:15 PM ET · Truist Park
The market has this one rightF5 CIN +165 / ATL −210 · fair odds 35.8 / 64.2 · total F5 4.5

Atlanta is a 64% favourite on a 1.86-run ERA gap, and the expected numbers put that gap at 1.83. Results and process agree to within three hundredths of a run.

Neither starter has been flattered: Singer's ERA sits 0.05 under his xERA, Mahle's 0.08 under his. There is nothing here to argue with, which is worth printing.

Against it  Singer's 10.1% barrel rate and 43% hard-hit are the contact profile of a pitcher who can lose five runs in an inning; the 64% may yet prove too low.

StarterIPERAxERAERA − xERAK%BB%Barrel%Hard-hit%
Brady SingerCIN · RHP154.05.675.72−0.0517.78.510.143.0
Tyler MahleATL · RHP144.03.813.89−0.0822.57.46.337.4
ATL at GB8:15 PM ET · Lambeau Field · Prime Video
No rating could be sourced, so no edge is claimedGB −4.5 · fair odds 31 / 69 · total 43.5

Atlanta arrive 0-2, Green Bay 1-1, and the consensus number is Packers by four and a half with a total of 43.5 — Covers and the Kalshi market agree on both.

One book is out of line with the rest: SportsbookReview shows BetRivers at Green Bay −6.5 against −4.5 at BetMGM and Caesars. Two points of spread between books on a nationally televised game is either the best number on the board or a bad scrape, and nothing tonight corroborated it.

Against it  ELWAY's team ratings live in interactive charts that do not render to a fetch, and Pro Football Reference returned 403. Without a rating there is no model number to set against the line, so this card states the market and stops there.

RecordsAtlanta 0-2 · Green Bay 1-1
SpreadGB −4.5 (Covers, Kalshi) · −4.5 to −6.5 across books at SBR
Total43.5
MarketKalshi implies Green Bay 69%
Atlanta outSamson Ebukam (hamstring) did not practise
Green Bay outJayden Reed (neck), Aaron Banks (toe), Warren Brinson (calf), Zach Bako-Bewele (knee)
Not carded. Four night games are not carded: Milwaukee at Philadelphia and Cleveland at Boston, where two sources named different starters; Tampa Bay at the Yankees, where only one source named them at all; and Houston at Oakland, where the two sources disagree on which team is at home.  ·  ERA − xERA negative means the results have outrun the contact.  ·  First-five moneylines from six books at SportsbookReview, margin removed. Season lines from each pitcher's Baseball Savant page. xFIP substitutes for SIERA, which no source will serve.  ·  Sources & methods
The Daily Lob Sources & methods